how do you know if you need to wear a knee brace?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/99119/99119c89739b4ca13e584dd1bd832bd87ed27680" alt="how do you know if you need to wear a knee brace? avatar m"
With respect: The argument to use a device “just to be safe” is faulty.
1) How do you know that a device is going to help the problem?
eg. A sleeve-type knee brace can give a little lateral support to the surrounding tissues, but in no way cushions the cartilage from jumping on a hard floor.
2) What if the device actually aggravates the problem?
eg. Wearing a brace too often can lead to muscle wasting, which actually weakens the knee.
___